Bedford Property Owners Win Right To Demolish Historic Tudor Structure Known - Bell Tower Preserved

Bedford Property Owners Win Right to Demolish Historic Tudor Structure Known - Bell Tower Preserved
On Tuesday, The Bedford Town Board heard the appeal of Dr.Darel Benaim and her husband Carlos in regards to their application to demolish an architecturally distinct structure on their property known as the Belfry.

The Benaim's had purchased the property on 44 Holly Branch Road in 2011 with the intent of tearing down the hundred year old building and incorporating home of stone, wood and glass into the rolling hill."Our real estate broker assured us we would be able to complete the designs in full compliance, said Dr.Benaim in addressing the board and public hearing.

Four months later, the couple was confronted with the Historical Building Preservation Ordinance and found their property among 500 other Bedford properties affected.Stopping their plans cold, she said, "We were shocked."

The ordinance calls for the preservation of properties and structures that contain distinctive architectural and historical significance.The point of contention has hinged on the transparency of the document.

The Benaim's claimed that they nor the various real estate and legal agents enlisted in the acquisition knew nothing of the Ordinance, and in fact, was not available to the public.

Otherwise, she said, "We never would have purchased the property."

In response, John Stockbridge, the Town of Bedford's Historian denied the so called "secrecy" of the list, as he argued in favor of the preservation of the Tudor Style structure for the Bedford Village Historic District Review Commission."There is no intent to have secrets.This is a survey that is available for people to look at," he said."Is it sent to everybody - no, but is the wetland map sent to everybody," he asked rhetorically.

In turn, he believed "due diligence" was not done in regards to the property owners and the real estate brokers and lawyers that acted on their behalf.He choose not to speculate on the intent of the various parties.

The main details in dispute aside, the board fashioned a compromise.The Benaim's will be able to demolish the main structure known as the Belfry but most preserve its signature Bell Tower.They can either relocate that or incorporate it into a new structure.Mr.Delbello confirmed that the Benaim's were satisfied with the ruling.

On the other end, Stockbridge was disappointed that the ordinance's intent did not fully stand up but was relieved that the Bell Tower was spared.He also recognized the bigger picture approach the town board was faced with.Pointing to possible ambiguities in any document and the willingness of the residents to continue the fight, he said, "Basically, they didn't want to get involved in an expensive, time consuming litigation."

Ultimately, he sees the outcome going forward as a wake up call for the commission."We need to be on the same page as the town board so if an ordinance is accepted, it can be relied upon by the public to get a proper review," he concluded. 

Article Written by richmonetti

I write and quite well


Post Your Comment

Related Articles

  • Human Rights Institute At Manhattanville College

    When Rosa Parks refused to yield her seat on an Alabama Bus, “she didn't know,” said Sleepy Hollow Junior Sophie Parens, but before anyone realized it, the small role she took, played a big part in changing the world. So could sum up a large part of the discussion and intent of the 10th annual Human Rights Institute for High School Student Leaders at Manhattanville College on March 16th.

  • Ardsley FastPitch Pitcher Excels In Sports And School

    Senior Madi Dinaso is a three sport standout at Ardsley. Closing her career with 12 of Ardsley’s 15 wins, the star pitcher dreams of playing softball in college, but not at the expense of what’s truly important.

    I’ve been looking at division three schools in New England with very good academic programs because that’s what matters to me most, says the soccer, softball and basketball player.

  • Cross River Chiropractor Brings His Care To The Sub Atomic Level With NES ProVision

    When we think of maintaining our health, the breakdown usually doesn't get smaller than the particular organ that our family or medical history demands. Medical science, on the other hand, certainly makes interventions on a molecular and cellular level but that's still way too big in comparison to thinking of Cross River Chiropractor Dr. Larry Stern and the wellness solution he is beginning to embark on with his clients.

    "The new medicine is Quantum physics," he says, and NES ProVision is the delivery.

  • Jeff Pearlman Comes Home To Discusses His Latest Book And The Life Of Walter Payton

    On Sunday, December 11th, Author Jeff Pearlman came back to his hometown of Mahopac, New York to discuss his most recent book Sweetness: The Enigmatic Life of Walter Payton. At the Mahopac Library, before an audience of about 30, Mr. Pearlman not only delved into the complex life of a giant but also the controversy he endured in light of an account that had much of the sports world aligned in outrage by the book's insights.

  • Bedford 2020 And Westchester Land Trust Host Water Quality Discussion At Fox Lane High School

    On Thursday night, April 12th, at the Fox Lane High School auditorium, the Bedford 2020 coalition and the Westchester Land Trust presented - Water, You are what you Drink. Aimed at linking the Bedford watershed system to human health, the audience was seated by watershed zones to highlight the obligation each
    person has in maintaining the present and future quality of the water we drink.

  • The Coffee House Is Home For Artists And Art Lovers In Peekskill

    If it's Sunday, it's Meet the Press, and while that's certainly true in my case, the day really means my weekly trip to Peekskill. There, I settle into the blue couch at the Peekskill Coffee House, where my writing acumen is engulfed in a sea of creative sights, sounds and smells.

  • The Mojomatics Radical Blues Tradition In Danbury, Connecticut

    The Mojomatics have existed in quite a few incantations since 1978 when lead singer Manny Foglio met guitarist Bill Barrett. On the other hand, by 1997, all the melodramatic rifts and revolving door chords were behind them, but was enough personal depression left to allow them to keep on singing the blues in Connecticut.

  • Soccer Runs In The Family And The Field For Fabian Chaparro Of Mamaroneck


    Mamaroneck soccer made an early first round exit from last year's sectionals. Their Captain Fabian Chaparro thinks this year will yield better results and a 2-0 start seems to indicate that. At the same time, Fabian's Soccer lineage is nothing to run away from and can only keep them moving in the right direction, according to their leader.

    "It pretty runs through the family," says the son of Uruguayan immigrants, "and hopefully my drive and passion helps push the team."

  • The Anterior Approach To Hip Replacement

    Hip replacement surgery has been an effective method of relieving debilitating hip pain and bringing back mobility since the 1960’s. Recovery, in the typical sense, usually requires on average about two to four months to complete. But unbeknownst to many considering the augmentation is a more recent method that more quickly returns people pain free to their feet and back to a mobility they once knew.

  • If I Had A Hammer

    I've spent the last 10 years working in a daycare surrounded mostly by women. So whenever something breaks, they come to me, reasoning that since I'm a guy I must be able to fix things. Regardless, it never sinks in no matter how many times I scold them, "My ability to fix a leaky pipe or unclog a stuffed up drain doesn't extend much beyond putting in a call to my mother to see if she knows the name of a good plumber.